Catnip vs. Silvervine: The Great Feline High Debate

Catnip vs. Silvervine: The Great Feline High Debate

 

Catnip vs. Silvervine: The Great Feline High Debate

 


If your cat suddenly goes wild, flips upside down, or rolls in a state of bliss, chances are you’ve given them catnip—or maybe silvervine. These two natural stimulants are like the feline version of a party favor, but which one is better? Is silvervine the new catnip? And why do some cats ignore one but go crazy for the other?


Let’s settle the debate and find out which “feline high” wins.

 

 

 

🌿 What Is Catnip?

 


Catnip (Nepeta cataria) is a member of the mint family and contains nepetalactone, a compound that triggers a euphoric response in many cats. Whether sniffed, rubbed, or eaten, catnip can cause:

 

  • Playfulness

  • Zoomies and rolling

  • Purring and drooling

  • Or… absolutely nothing

 


That’s right—not all cats respond to catnip. Sensitivity is genetic, and roughly 30–40% of cats feel no effects at all.

 

 

 

🍂 What Is Silvervine?

 


Silvervine (Actinidia polygama) is a climbing vine native to Asia and used in traditional medicine—and increasingly, in cat toys. It contains two active ingredients: actinidine and dihydronepetalactone, which produce a stronger and more consistent response in cats.


Silvervine tends to:

 

  • Trigger more intense reactions than catnip

  • Be effective for cats who ignore catnip

  • Last longer and create more variety in behaviors (e.g., licking, chewing, rubbing)

Feature

Catnip

Silvervine

Active Compound

Nepetalactone

Actinidine + Dihydronepetalactone

Response Rate

~60–70% of cats respond

~80%+ of cats respond

Strength of Reaction

Mild to Moderate

Moderate to Intense

Forms Available

Dried herb, sprays, infused toys

Powder, sticks, infused toys

Origin

Europe, Middle East

Japan, China, Korea

 

😻 Which One Should You Use?

 


If your cat enjoys catnip—great! Stick with it. But if they’re indifferent, silvervine could be the magic key to their joy. You can also combine both for a sensory treat or alternate them to keep the experience fresh.


Pro tip: Look for toys that include both herbs for maximum feline engagement.

 

 

 

🧠 Are These “Highs” Safe?

 


Yes. Both catnip and silvervine are non-addictive and safe in moderation. Overexposure may lead to a short-term tolerance, so limit sessions to 2–3 times per week and always supervise their play.


Signs of overuse might include:

 

  • Brief disinterest or zoning out

  • Digestive upset if large amounts are eaten

 


If you’re ever unsure, consult your vet—especially for kittens, seniors, or cats with medical conditions.

 

 

 

🐱 Final Verdict: Silvervine Wins (Slightly)

 


While catnip remains a classic, silvervine takes the crown for being more universally effective and often more intense. But the real winner is your cat—especially when you give them the choice to experience both.


So go ahead, start the ultimate feline field test:

Catnip in one corner, silvervine in the other. Let the games begin.

 

 

 

SEO Tags:

 

 

  • catnip vs silvervine

  • is silvervine better than catnip

  • catnip alternatives

  • what does silvervine do to cats

  • natural cat stimulants

 

 

 

Back to blog